Using ChatGPT to Prep for 6th Grade Subbing
I have forced myself to sign up to substitute teach for a middle school science class. I made a goal to experience elementary through high school as a sub and I’m sticking to it. I'm turning to ChatGPT to help me prep.
I promised to be unfiltered in my writing … so here we go. 🤠
I’m dreading this specific substitute experience because:
- I have ZERO experience with 6th graders, or any middle schoolers, or any elementary schoolers… in any setting whatsoever. The “what if” questions are spiraling. It's odd that it's legal for me to do this. If I were a parent, I would not be happy that my child was spending time with such an inexperienced person.
- The slot is 7am - 3pm. Idk if there are breaks. I’m a 8am natural wakeup type who’s schedule hasn’t been challenged in several years as a remote software developer consultant. Poor me. Reframed: It’ll be good to get in the habit of waking up earlier.
- There doesn’t appear to be a sub plan … so I’ll have to think of something cool to do with no idea what they’ve already learned or not. This sounds fun though.
- I have heard that 6th graders are hard. Although I’ve heard that from every other age as well so 🤷🏼♀️
How old are 6th graders?
Can you speak to a 6th grader like a normal adult?
Can 6th graders control their bodies?
What do 6th graders know going into science class?
What do 6th graders learn in science class?
What are common things 6th graders are excited about in general?
What are current 6th grade fads?
I am substitute teaching for a 6th grade science class in the United States tomorrow. I have little experience with children, including 6th graders and very minimal experience as a substitute teacher at all.
Please answer the following and provide examples:
1. How do you speak to a 6th grader compared to a high schooler?
2. What general capabilities does a 6th grader (on average) have compared to a 4th grader?
3. What general capabilities does a 6th grader (on average) not have compared to a 9th grader?
4. Separately reframe questions 2 and 3 to answer specifically academic capabilities comparatively.
See full GPT-4 responses at the end.
My prompting certainly needs improving.
I’m not surprised when I get answers along the lines of “6th graders can handle more complexity than 4th graders and less than 9th graders” … which are pretty useless since I don’t know what 4th graders can handle (or 9th graders even though I subbed for 9th grade Math) and if I asked the same question it would cite the same comparison for 2nd graders and 12 graders and the loop would continue until it’s an unborn child.
Adding on the obvious fact that there is a wide band of capability at any age I realize I’m prompting a LLM hoping to get easy answers and prove me wrong that it’ll be human trial-and-error throwing out words they might know and adjusting rapidly from there.
Provide three examples of lesson plans a teacher might have for a 6th grade science class.
This one, not surprisingly was more useful. I get Solar Systems, Weather and Climate, Ecosystems and Food Webs in my back pocket with an outline of how to conduct the lesson. Although, my memory of those are foggy (😂) so I’ll write re-write the prompt to help me brush up on them and actually write out what specifically to teach during these lessons.
Please re-outline the first two examples of lesson plans but also include the content for the plan.
For example when you said "Introduce the solar system and its components (planets, moons, asteroids, etc.)" please actually write how to introduce it.
Additionally, for each lesson, include a succinct summary of the lesson in the context of catching the teacher up with the content they have forgotten over the 20 years since they've learned it.
🎯 Nailed it. I now have 3 different lesson plans that have the actual step-by-step instructions for how to conduct. Example: Begin by asking students if they can name any planets in our solar system. The teacher summary at the end is also amazing. (I miss Pluto being a planet though). Now I think I can add in some human creativity to this like showing the video of Starship’s recent launch attempt or other current events that create relevancy.
I will likely tweak the prompt even more to provide lessons that don’t require supplies since I’m not going to buy PlayDough for a lesson that might never happen if there turns out to be a sub plan.
The best would be if kids draw out of a hat what solar system object they are, get 10 minutes to learn about that element on their phone or computer on their own, and then we build the human solar system and sequentially outwards from the sun the kids callout a fact about their object. I assume the school doesn’t restrict internet searches. The high school restricted ChatGPT and I felt helpless when I wanted to use it to quickly remind me how to divide polynomials to then be able to help students who were working on that. Discussing the point, or lack thereof of learning to divide polynomials by hand will be a separate post.
Anyways … I shall report back once I’ve actually completed my first middle school substitute teaching experience. I am not allowed to back out even though I’d really like to.
GPT-4 Response 1
- Speaking to a 6th grader compared to a high schooler:
- When speaking to a 6th grader, use age-appropriate vocabulary, simpler sentence structures, and a friendly tone. Encourage questions and maintain an approachable demeanor. With high school students, you can use more complex language, explore deeper topics, and engage in more abstract discussions.For example, when explaining a scientific concept to a 6th grader, you might say: "Photosynthesis is when plants use sunlight to make food for themselves." For a high schooler, you could say: "Photosynthesis is the process by which plants convert light energy into chemical energy to fuel their growth."
- General capabilities of a 6th grader compared to a 4th grader:
- Sixth graders typically have better reading comprehension, improved writing skills, and a greater ability to think critically. They can handle more complex tasks and are more likely to work independently. Sixth graders can engage in group discussions, follow multi-step directions, and solve problems with multiple variables.
- General capabilities a 6th grader may not have compared to a 9th grader:
- Sixth graders often have limited experience with abstract thinking, advanced problem-solving, and in-depth analysis of complex issues. They may struggle to comprehend more advanced scientific concepts, engage in high-level mathematical operations, or produce well-structured and nuanced essays.
- Academic capabilities:
- Compared to a 4th grader, a 6th grader can understand more complex scientific concepts, perform operations with fractions and decimals, and write organized paragraphs with supporting evidence.
- Compared to a 9th grader, a 6th grader may struggle with advanced algebra, understanding the subtleties of literary analysis, or engaging in scientific inquiry that requires a deep understanding of various scientific disciplines.
GPT-4 Response 2
Three examples of lesson plans for a 6th-grade science class:
- Exploring the Solar System
- Introduce the solar system and its components (planets, moons, asteroids, etc.).
- Discuss the characteristics of each planet, including size, distance from the sun, and surface conditions.
- Activity: Have students create a scale model of the solar system using everyday objects.
- Weather and Climate:
- Define weather and climate, and explain the factors that influence them.
- Discuss the water cycle, air masses, and fronts.
- Activity: Have students create a weather forecast for their local area using real-time weather data.
- Ecosystems and Food Webs:
- Introduce the concept of ecosystems and the various biomes on Earth.
- Explain food chains and food webs, emphasizing the role of producers, consumers, and decomposers.
- Activity: Have students create a food web for a specific ecosystem, identifying producers, consumers, and decomposers.
GPT-4 Response 2 Revised ⭐️
Example 1: Exploring the Solar System
Lesson Plan: I. Introduction (5 minutes)
- Begin by asking students if they can name any planets in our solar system.
- Explain that our solar system consists of the sun, eight planets, moons, asteroids, and other celestial objects.
II. The Solar System Components (20 minutes)
- Present a visual aid (poster, slideshow, or video) showing the solar system.
- Briefly describe each planet's characteristics (size, distance from the sun, atmosphere, etc.).
- Discuss other celestial bodies like moons, asteroids, and comets.
III. Activity: Scale Model of the Solar System (20 minutes)
- Divide students into groups and provide materials for creating scale models (e.g., playdough, beads, string).
- Assign each group a planet to research and create a model of, including the correct relative size and distance from the sun.
- Have groups present their models to the class, explaining their planet's unique features.
IV. Conclusion (5 minutes)
- Review the main points of the lesson and emphasize the vastness of the solar system.
- Encourage students to explore more about space and astronomy on their own.
Summary for the teacher: The solar system consists of the sun, eight planets (Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune), their moons, and other celestial objects like asteroids and comets. The planets orbit the sun in elliptical paths, and their features and distances from the sun vary greatly.
Example 2: Weather and Climate
Lesson Plan: I. Introduction (5 minutes)
- Ask students to describe the weather outside today and explain the difference between weather and climate.
- Explain that weather is the short-term atmospheric conditions, while climate is the long-term average of those conditions.
II. Factors Influencing Weather and Climate (15 minutes)
- Discuss the water cycle, air masses, and fronts, explaining their roles in determining weather conditions.
- Introduce the main factors affecting climate, such as latitude, altitude, and proximity to bodies of water.
III. Activity: Local Weather Forecast (20 minutes)
- Divide students into groups and provide access to real-time weather data (e.g., from a weather website or app).
- Instruct each group to create a weather forecast for the next three days, considering temperature, precipitation, and other relevant factors.
- Have groups present their forecasts to the class.
IV. Conclusion (5 minutes)
- Review the main points of the lesson and emphasize the importance of understanding weather and climate in daily life.
Summary for the teacher: Weather refers to short-term atmospheric conditions, while climate is the long-term average of those conditions. The water cycle, air masses, and fronts are key factors that influence weather. Climate is affected by factors such as latitude, altitude, and proximity to bodies of water.